20世纪30年代凯恩斯与哈耶克之争:同袍抑或敌手
Keynes and Hayek in 1930s: Comrade Or Rival
-
摘要: 长期以来,国内外学术界对于凯恩斯与哈耶克的理论对手形象根深蒂固。然而,近几十年的经济思想史研究告诉我们,这一理论对手的形象反映出来的是我们对凯恩斯与哈耶克关于货币、资本和商业周期论述的误读有多深。本文通过对1930年代发生在两者之间的著名争论详加探究,综合近年来的经济思想史研究成果发现:至少在维克赛尔的分析传统之下,凯恩斯与哈耶克远不是彼此对立的敌手,而是并肩作战的同袍;现代宏观经济学的发展之所以偏离了两者当年研究的方向,乃是经济学界职业发展的内在逻辑而非经济学议题的重要性使然。Abstract: For a long time, the academic circles at home and abroad have been deeply rooted in the image of Keynes and Hayek. However, the study of the history of economic thought in recent decades tells us that the image of this adversary reflects the depth of our misreading of Keynes, Hayek’s monetary, capital, and business cycles. The famous dispute in between the two on 1930s detailed inquiry, comprehensive recent research achievements in the history of economic thought shows that at least under the traditional analysis of Wicksell, Keynes and Hayek is not against each other but the comrades; the development of modern macroeconomics has deviated from the direction of the two economists’ studys, in which the internal logic dictates the importance of economics occupation development rather than economic issues.
-

计量
- 文章访问数: 1936
- HTML全文浏览量: 271