青年马克思是如何批判黑格尔的—《1844年经济学哲学手稿》笔记本III再考察
How did Young Marx Criticize Hegel
-
摘要: 《1844年经济学哲学手稿》笔记本III中[对黑格尔的辩证法和整个哲学的批判]是马克思黑格尔关系研究中最为经典的文本依据。这一部分的写作是分三个阶段进行的,其中插入了[私有财产和需要]以及[增补]的主体部分。依据写作过程的考察,可以发现:1844年,马克思对黑格尔的批判最初是在运用费尔巴哈批判施特劳斯和鲍威尔的意义上展开的,但是随着研究的推进,马克思意识到黑格尔站在国民经济学家的立场上,在异化的规定内包含着积极的环节。一方面,这构成了马克思进一步研究政治经济学,对抽象力量奴役人的现实以及黑格尔辩证法展开批判的新起点。另一方面,其中也包含着对费尔巴哈人本主义的潜在理论溢出。在这个意义上,《1844年经济学哲学手稿》可以被看作新唯物主义的发源地。Abstract: In conventional studies on Marx-Engels relations,[Critique of the Hegelian Dialectic and Philosophy as a Whole]in Heft III of Economic and Philosophic Manuscripts of 1844 was the most cited text. The writing of this text could be divided to 3 stages, among which are the fragments on private property and human needs. In the first stage, Marx criticized Hegel with Feuerbach in order to elucidate the secret of D. Strauss and B. Bauer. In the second and the third, Marx realized that Hegel stood on the standpoint of national economist, and discovered the positive moments of Hegelian dialectic within the rule of alienation. It could be considered as the new starting point of Marx’s studies of political economy and his critique of the abstract power ruling human beings. Meanwhile, it included the potential critique of the humanism in Feuerbach. I therefore proposed that Economic and Philosophic Manuscripts of 1844 is the cradle of Marx’s new materialism.
-
Key words:
- dialectic /
- Feuerbach /
- materialism /
- labour
-
马克思标序 内容 MEGA2编者判定 I—II [私有财产和劳动] 第一阶段 III [私有财产和劳动][私有财产和共产主义] 第二阶段 III—XIII
XIV—XVII[私有财产和共产主义][对黑格尔的辩证法和整个哲学的批判]
[私有财产和需要]第三阶段
第三阶段XIII,XVII—XVIII [对黑格尔的辩证法和整个哲学的批判] 第四阶段 XVIII—XXI [增补] 第五阶段 XXII—XXXIV [对黑格尔的辩证法和整个哲学的批判] 第六阶段 XXXIV—XXXVIII [增补][分工] 第七阶段 XXXIX—XL 序言 第八阶段 XLI—XLIII [货币] 第九阶段 -

计量
- 文章访问数: 1708
- HTML全文浏览量: 91