在体系性与历史性之间:《资本论》的辩证法
Between Systematicity and Historicity: The Dialectics of Das Kapital
-
摘要: 关于《资本论》辩证法不同形态的理解,形成了体系辩证法和历史辩证法两种解读模式。体系辩证法强调经济范畴的体系性关系和逻辑优先性,是将马克思辩证法思想中的“黑格尔因素”释放出来的方法。历史辩证法则从逻辑抽象的历史前提和社会生产的历史先决条件展开论证。《资本论》辩证法的形态争议,需要回到马克思写作《资本论》的原初目的和文本结构中去理解。《资本论》辩证法的研究对象是基于资本主义诸经济范畴内在关联而形成的总体,《资本论》叙述结构的变更原因就是抽象范畴的不断具体化,促使马克思完善了劳动价值论和剩余价值理论,并最终形成了《资本论》的科学结构。《资本论》叙述结构的变更,意味着马克思从注重经济范畴的逻辑关系转向加强具体环节的实证分析,《资本论》辩证法从体系性偏向了历史性。《资本论》辩证法的具体运用是资本主义经济范畴的逻辑演绎和社会现实的实证分析二元方法的结合。体系性和历史性共同规定着《资本论》辩证法的基本结构和理论目的,体系性和历史性之间的矛盾张力反而增强了辩证法批判现实的能力。Abstract: Different understandings of the dialectics in Das Kapital have given rise to two interpretive models: systematic dialectics and historical dialectics. Systematic dialectics emphasizes the systematic relationships and logical priority of economic categories. It is a method that unleashes the "Hegelian elements" in Marx's dialectical thought. Historical dialectics, on the other hand, unfolds its arguments from the historical premises of logical abstractions and the historical preconditions of social production. To understand the controversy over the forms of the dialectics in Das Kapital, we need to return to Marx's original purpose of writing Das Kapital and the textual structure. The research object of the dialectics in Das Kapital is an entirety formed by the internal connections of various economic categories of capitalism. The reason for the change in the narrative structure of Das Kapital is the continuous concretization of abstract categories, which impelled Marx to perfect the labor theory of value and the theory of surplus value, and ultimately form the scientific structure of Das Kapital. The change in the narrative structure of Das Kapital implies that Marx shifted from emphasizing the logical relationships of economic categories to strengthening the empirical analysis of specific links, and the dialectics in Das Kapital tilted from systematicity towards historicity. The specific application of the dialectics in Das Kapital is the combination of the dual methods of logical deduction of capitalist economic categories and empirical analysis of social reality. Both systematicity and historicity jointly determine the basic structure and theoretical purpose of the dialectics in Das Kapital. Paradoxically, the contradictory tension between systematicity and historicity enhances the dialectics' ability to criticize reality.
-
Key words:
- Das Kapital /
- systematicity /
- historicity /
- totality /
- concreteness /
- empirical analysis
-

计量
- 文章访问数: 34
- HTML全文浏览量: 10