人工智能体有自由意志吗
作者简介:南星,北京大学哲学系/外国哲学研究所助理教授(北京 100871)
摘要: 随着人工智能技术的高速发展,人工智能体变得越来越自主,以至于人们会很自然地对它们是否拥有自由意志产生疑问。然而,传统哲学中的主流观点以及大多数人的直觉都会否认机器拥有自由意志的可能性。在经典的“反应态度”理论的基础上,可发展出一种“实践自由”的概念,人工智能体可以满足这一概念所要求的两个重要条件,即行为的不可预测性和潜在冲突的目标,但在对期待和要求的共同认可这一关键条件上会面临十分严重的困难。通过对人工智能体拥有自由意志的可能性条件进行分析,我们能够更深入地理解(人类)自由意志的本性和基础。
Do Artificial Agents Have Free Will?
- Available Online:
2021-01-20
Abstract: With the new developments in artificial intelligence research, artificial agents (AAs) become more and more autonomous, thus it is natural to suspect that they might, to certain extent, have free will. However, according to the mainstream view in traditional philosophy as well as to most people’s intuition, it is impossible to attribute free will to any machine. This paper engages in this debate by developing a concept of “practical freedom” on the basis of the classic “reactive attitudes” theory. It argues that, while AAs may satisfy two important conditions required by the concept of practical freedom, i.e., the unpredictability of behavior and the potentially conflicting goals, they can hardly satisfy the key condition of mutual recognition of expectations and requirements, thus are unlikely to be regarded as having freedom of will in the near future. Through the analysis of the possible conditions of the freedom of will of AAs, this paper also aims to deepen our understanding of the nature and foundation of the freedom of will (in humans).