复合理性:当代公共行政理性的整合性范式
作者简介:袁方成,深圳大学政府管理学院教授、全球特大型城市治理研究院研究员(广东深圳 518055)。
基金项目:
本文为阐释党的二十届三中全会精神国家社科基金重大专项“转变城市发展方式的理论内涵、实践路径和机制保障研究”(24ZDA051)的阶段性成果
摘要: 当代公共行政面临跨域议题、价值多元与治理网络化等复杂挑战,形式理性、工具理性与价值理性等传统范式已难以有效应对。作为整合性范式,复合理性强调通过技术理性、价值理性与交往理性的有机整合,在政策过程中实现多元理性要素的动态融合与协同适配,从而提升治理体系的包容性与适应性。复合理性的提出,旨在弥合传统理性范式的分野,推动治理思维由二元对立走向整合平衡,同时增强公共决策的合法性、社会认同和政策创新能力。其核心机制包括科层体系与网络关系的双重嵌入、规则与情境的协同适配及多元价值的动态平衡。
Composite Rationality: An Integrative Paradigm of Rationality in Contemporary Public Administration
Abstract: Modern public administration faces complex challenges such as transboundary issues,value pluralism,and networked governance,which traditional paradigms like formal rationality,instrumental rationality,and value rationality struggle to effectively address.As an integrative paradigm,composite rationality emphasizes the organic integration of technical rationality,value rationality,and communicative rationality to achieve the dynamic fusion and synergistic adaptation of multiple rational elements within the policy process,thereby enhancing the inclusiveness and adaptability of the governance system.The proposition of composite rationality aims to bridge the divide among traditional rational paradigms,foster a shift in governance thinking from binary oppositions towards an integrated equilibrium,and simultaneously enhance the legitimacy of public decision-making,social acceptance,and policy innovation capacity.Its core mechanisms include the dual embeddedness of bureaucratic structures and network relations,the collaborative adaptation between rules and situational contexts,and a dynamic equilibrium among diverse values.