艺术之争背后的经济学——罗斯金与惠斯勒的官司
Economics Behind Art Conflict——A Reexamination of Ruskin-Whistler Lawsuit
-
摘要: 罗斯金—惠斯勒诉讼案是西方艺术史上的一个重要事件,既往研究大多聚焦于两人艺术理念不同,其实,两人的艺术之争有更深层次的社会经济原因。结合罗斯金后期被忽视的社会理论、马克思主义理论以及消费文化理论,可从跨学科的经济学视角再审视这场诉讼案。罗斯金与惠斯勒之争可追溯到社会由供给时代转向消费时代背景下两人对艺术品生产与消费的不同观念。罗斯金的经济学思想以劳动价值论为核心,与马克思主义经济学具有一致性。他认为商品具有固有的内在价值,应当根据生产中凝结的劳动来定价,否定交换价值,反对消费主义;而艺术品不同于普通商品,承载着提升社会道德的责任。惠斯勒对形式的关注体现了消费时代商品的非功能性,他的作品以其前卫、新颖在视觉文化主导的消费社会中受到了公众的追捧,顺应了消费时代的到来。罗斯金始终坚持艺术的救赎功能,而惠斯勒的成功标志了审美资本化时代的开启。Abstract: The Ruskin-Whistler lawsuit is an important event in the history of Western art.While previous studies mostly focus on their different artistic views, this article points out that the artistic dispute can be traced back to deeper socio-economic reasons.It explores into the neglected social theory of Ruskin in his later period and resorts to Marxist economic theory as well the consumption culture theory, in order to re-examine this lawsuit from the interdisciplinary perspective of economics.The dispute between Ruskin and Whistler lies in their different concepts on art production and consumption when the society transited from the era of supply to that of consumption.Ruskin's economic theory focuses on the labor theory of value and conforms to Marxist economics.He believes that commodities have fixed intrinsic value and negates exchange value as well as consumerism, arguing that commodities should be priced according to the labor cost in production.Art differs from common commodities and undertakes the duty of promoting social morality.Whistler adapted himself to the changes of the times.His works gained public applause due to their avant-garde and novelty in a consumer society dominated by visual culture.His focus on form reflects the non-functional nature of commodities in the consumer era.Ruskin insists on the redemptive function of art, while Whistler's success marks the beginning of the era of the capitalization of aesthetics.
-
Key words:
- Ruskin /
- Whistler /
- price of art /
- labor theory of value /
- consumer culture
-

计量
- 文章访问数: 4
- HTML全文浏览量: 1