摘要:
违法性认识理论司法适用困境的成因是我国《刑法》没有明确规定违法性认识是犯罪成立要素,并且司法实践中尚无违法性认识及其可能性如何影响故意和过失成立的具体操作标准。基于信赖保护的刑事政策立场,违法性认识理论必须在中国刑法自主知识体系中获得妥当位置。中国《刑法》中违法性认识是故意和过失共同的成立要素,这可以从《刑法》对故意和过失的规定中找到规范依据,并且在犯罪论体系上也具有合理性。将法定犯按照主体是一般人还是专业人,以及主观构成要件是故意、过失还是故意和过失可以分为五类。针对五类法定犯分别提出违法性认识及其可能性的程度如何影响故意和过失成立的判断标准,进而实现紧密契合现代中国社会发展需要和中国《刑法》规定的违法性认识理论范式构建。
Abstract:
The judicial application dilemma of the theory of consciousness of illegality lies in the fact that China's Criminal Law does not explicitly stipulate that consciousness of illegality is an element of crime,and there is no specific operational standard in judicial practice regarding how consciousness of illegality and its possibility affect the establishment of intent and negligence.It must be recognized that the incorporation of the theory of consciousness of illegality into the criminal law system is a necessary measure to protect the public's trust in legal norms and even in their freedom of action,as well as an inevitable demand of modern society for a modern criminal law.Moreover,the theory of consciousness of illegality takes the protection of citizens' reliance in their freedom of action as its theoretical foundation and focuses on safeguarding such trust as its primary content.Therefore,it is feasible to explore the theory of consciousness of illegality from the standpoint of reliance protection.From the perspective of criminal policy based on reliance protection,the theory of consciousness of illegality must be appropriately positioned within China's autonomous criminal law knowledge system.In China's Criminal Law,consciousness of illegality serves as a common element for both intent and negligence,which can be derived from the normative basis in the provisions on intent and negligence in the Criminal Law and is also reasonable within the framework of the criminal theory system.Statutory offenses can be categorized into five types based on whether the subject is a layperson or a professional,and whether the subjective element is intent,negligence,or both.For each of these five categories,specific criteria can be proposed to determine how the degree of consciousness of illegality and its possibility affects the establishment of intent and negligence.This approach will facilitate the construction of a theoretical paradigm of consciousness of illegality that closely aligns with the developmental needs of modern Chinese society and the stipulations of China's Criminal Law.