多元人文主义视域下的普实克与夏志清
作者简介:周寻,北京印刷学院基础教育学院讲师(北京102600)。
摘要: 源起西欧的人文主义历史复杂、意涵丰富、面向多元。通过追溯人文主义的起源、梳理其内涵与外延的历时性沿革,可以包容性地理解西方思想史中人文主义的概念。以人文主义为思想脉络和话语框架对普实克和夏志清的海外中国现代文学研究的学理原则进行学术性的考察、反思与批判,既能够获取对两位学者学术差异的语境化理解,也有助于进一步探索人文主义的多元意涵。在多元人文主义的视域下,夏志清和普实克对中国现代文学的认识同属于人文主义的传统。在二者各自学术资源、文学史观、治学方法、文化关怀和政治倾向等方面的共同作用下,夏志清和普实克的学术研究分别呈现了人文主义自由的一元与激进的一元。由此重审普实克与夏志清对中国文学世界性的不同呈现,或可为当下学界探索呈现中国文学世界性的路径与方法提供经验和启示。
An Examination of Jaroslav Prek and C.T.Hsia from the Perspective of Humanism with Its Diversity
Abstract: Originating in Western Europe,humanism has a complex history,rich connotations,and multiple orientations.By tracing the origins of humanism and sorting out its diachronic connotations and extensions,the concept of humanism in the history of Western thought is understood in an inclusive manner.Using humanism as an ideological lineage and discourse framework to academically examine,reflect on,and critique the theoretical principles of Jaroslav Preks and C.T.Hsias overseas modern Chinese literature studies,we can not only gain a contextualized understanding of the academic differences between the two scholars,but also help further explore the pluralistic meanings of humanism.From the perspective of humanism with its diversity,both Preks and Hsias cognition of modern Chinese literature belongs to the humanist tradition.With their individual academic resources,views on literary history,academic approaches,cultural concerns,and ideologies,Hsia and Prek studied and presented Chinese literature employing the ideas of liberal humanism and radical humanism respectively in their scholarship.Thus,an examination of Prek and Hsia as two exemplary cases to analyze how different paradigms of overseas study present cosmopolitanism in modern Chinese literature and the humanistic ideas behind these paradigms may provide experience and inspiration for the current academic community to explore the paths and methods of presenting Chinese literary cosmopolitanism.