司法信任如何影响人工智能裁判的可接受度——基于问卷调查的实证研究
How Does Public Trust in the Judiciary Shape Acceptability of Judges' AI-assisted Adjudications——An Empirical Study Based on Questionnaire Data
-
摘要: 揭示司法信任如何影响AI裁判的可接受度,有助于理解和提升当前数字司法改革的公众基础。本研究基于537份调查问卷,采用结构方程模型进行实证分析,结果发现:在数字司法语境下,民众的司法信任仍能影响AI裁判的可接受度,但与此同时,民众的技术信任正成为影响AI裁判可接受度的重要因素,二者共同塑造着民众对AI裁判的态度。在影响机制上,司法信任主要通过民众的公正感知来影响其对AI裁判的可接受度;其中,程序公正感知在数字司法语境中较实体公正感知更为重要。为提升民众对AI裁判的可接受度,应坚持AI在司法裁判中的辅助定位,依托司法信任基础助推数字司法改革;依据繁简分流标准界定AI裁判的介入程度,保障复杂个案的实体公正得到兼顾;围绕“以审判为中心”建立AI裁判的配套制度,降低技术应用对程序公正的负面影响。Abstract: Unpacking how public trust in the judiciary shapes public acceptance of judges' AI-assisted adjudications is crucial to consolidating public support for ongoing digital judicial reforms. Drawing on valid data from 537 questionnaires,an empirical analysis with structural equation modeling demonstrates that public trust in the judiciary remains a key predictor of public acceptance of AI-assisted judicial rulings in digital justice scenarios. Meanwhile,public trust in technology has also become a salient predictor of public acceptance of AI-assisted judges' rulings. Together,these two constructs jointly determine public attitudes toward AI-assisted adjudications. Regarding its underlying mechanisms,public trust in the judiciary shapes acceptance of AI-assisted adjudications primarily via citizens' fairness perceptions. Among such fairness perceptions,procedural fairness exerts a stronger predictive effect than substantive fairness within digital justice frameworks. To enhance public acceptance of AI-assisted judicial rulings,policymakers should retain AI as an auxiliary tool in judicial decision-making and capitalize on existing public trust in the judiciary to promote the digital justice reform. The scope of AI participation should be calibrated based on case complexity to safeguard substantive fairness in the complex cases. Furthermore,specialized supporting procedural rules for AI-assisted adjudications should be formulated to offset the negative effects of technology on procedural fairness.
-
点击查看大图
计量
- 文章访问数: 24
- HTML全文浏览量: 5
下载:
沪公网安备 31010102003103号