事件是如何生成的？

侯旭东

English

事件是如何生成的？

侯旭东

引用本文: 侯旭东. 事件是如何生成的？[J]. 学术月刊, 2019, 51(11): 158-178. shu

Citation: Xudong HOU. How an Event Was Produced[J]. Academic Monthly, 2019, 51(11): 158-178. shu

事件是如何生成的？—道光的日常与“鸦片战争”作为事件的形成

侯旭东

作者简介: 侯旭东，清华大学人文学院历史系教授（北京 100084）;

中图分类号: K25

How an Event Was Produced

Xudong HOU

Available Online: 2019-11-01
CLC number: K25

摘要: 借助相对更接近历史现场的《起居注》，从道光十二年闰九月观察道光十八年到二十二年，看这几年的经历如何生成为“鸦片战争”的“历史叙述”。拉长镜头，尽可能贴近其中一个现场，顺时而观，从经历，到散落在时序中的记录，到秘密编纂的分类事务（夷务），到事件，再到划时代的事件。对照清朝自身的“事件”生产机制，可以看清在不同目的的驱使下，时人的经历与处置、事后诸人的思考、外人的叙述如何交汇，时人如何“失语”，后人如何控制了历史叙述，“事件”如何从经历中脱颖而出、意义又是如何被不断增添、改变与筛减的，“事件”形成后又如何变为重返历史现场的一层障碍。了解这些，我们便有可能从更多的角度去重新发现这段历史，并对“事件史”的意义与局限有更真切的认识。
- 起居注 /
- 日常 /
- 鸦片战争 /
- 事件史 /
- 历史叙述
Abstract: Through the Court Dairies of the Daoguang period, which is much more close to one of the original historical sites, we could see how the rich court affairs between 1838 and 1842 documented in it were selected and compiled as the lean narratives tabbed as the Opium War eventually by taking the Court Dairies of the intercalary month of 1832(Sep.) as a mirror. We will also make clear how the ruling group’s efforts finally has been transformed into an epoch-making event through a series steps from scattered and trivial matters on Sino-British battles due to opium trades kept in archives, then to the classified affairs (Barbarian matters) compiled secretly in 1850’s under Xianfeng’s decree, and to an event, by returning to the past along time sequence and close to one of the historical sites as much as possible. Comparing to Qing Empire’s own event-producing mechanism, we could distinguish how those contemporaries’ experiences, the recalling from people afterwards, and the narratives coming from later generations and outsiders combine together, how the contemporaries fall into the victim of aphasia finally, how the later generations dominate the voices of historical narratives, how the event was made depending on contemporaries experiences, how the significances has been added, distorted, and reduced interrelatedly and constantly, and how the event becomes a kind of hindrance for posterity if we want to return to the original historical site after the production of the event as a story. Understanding all of these, we could rediscover the history of these years from more diverse perspectives, and know much about the implications and limitations of the history of events as a way of thinking.
- Court Dairies /
- routinized life /
- Opium War /
- history events /
- historical narration
1. [1]
  皮国立 . 湿之为患：明清江南的医疗、环境与日常生活史. 学术月刊, 2017, 49(09): 131-144.
2. [2]
  庞学铨 . 重建日常生活经验世界. 学术月刊, 2021, 53(1): 23-34.
3. [3]
  张剑波 , 桑玉成 . 战争与国家形成的学术史探析. 学术月刊, 2022, 54(7): 93-106.
4. [4]
  张振国 . 清代道府请训与日常政务运作——兼论召见书写及其特点. 学术月刊, 2023, 55(5): 202-216.
5. [5]
  陶赋雯 . 历史罪证的“记忆场”：军歌与日本的战争记忆. 学术月刊, 2024, 56(2): 175-186.
6. [6]
  葛兆光 . 一个历史事件的旅行 ——“文艺复兴”在东亚近代思想和学术中的影响. 学术月刊, 2016, 48(03): 120-127.
7. [7]
  杨乃乔 . 口传注经与诠释历史的真值性（上） —— 兼论公羊学的诠释学传统和体例及其他. 学术月刊, 2016, 48(09): 110-124.
8. [8]
  杨乃乔 . 口传注经与诠释历史的真值性（下）—— 兼论公羊学的诠释学传统和体例及其他. 学术月刊, 2016, 48(10): 109-122.
9. [9]
  徐坚 . 三角缘神兽镜再检讨：从金石学、以物证史到历史考古学. 学术月刊, 2022, 54(3): 193-200.
10. [10]
  陈晓明 . 乡村自然史与激进现代性——《白鹿原》与“90年代”的历史源起. 学术月刊, 2018, 50(5): 111-127.
11. [11]
  仇鹿鸣 . 事件、过程与政治文化. 学术月刊, 2019, 51(10): 160-171.
12. [12]
  秦中亮 . “永王李璘事件”发微. 学术月刊, 2017, 49(11): 150-184.
13. [13]
  肖锦龙 . 西方当下事件理论动向管窥. 学术月刊, 2021, 53(10): 154-161.
14. [14]
  杨国荣 . “事”与“史”. 学术月刊, 2019, 51(1): 11-23.
15. [15]
  李晓愚 . 图像如何“为史”. 学术月刊, 2022, 54(12): 153-164.
16. [16]
  郜积意 , 曾新桂 . 礼经郑注“馔要方”图释. 学术月刊, 2023, 55(1): 173-190.
17. [17]
  黄平 . 王小波与文学史. 学术月刊, 2017, 49(12): 134-143.
18. [18]
  景海峰 . 从经学到经学史. 学术月刊, 2019, 51(11): 5-14.
19. [19]
  易承志，杜依灵，张翔 . 公共灾害性事件缘何“再发生”——基于危机学习的理论视角. 学术月刊, 2023, 55(10): 88-98.
20. [20]
  褚潇白 . 论作为语言事件的“中国基督教跨文化现象”. 学术月刊, 2018, 50(6): 89-103.

点击查看大图

计量

PDF下载量: 25
文章访问数: 1719
HTML全文浏览量: 320

通讯作者: 陈斌, bchen63@163.com

1.
沈阳化工大学材料科学与工程学院沈阳 110142

事件是如何生成的？

侯旭东

作者简介:侯旭东，清华大学人文学院历史系教授（北京 100084）

网络出版日期: 2019-11-01

关键词:

摘要: 借助相对更接近历史现场的《起居注》，从道光十二年闰九月观察道光十八年到二十二年，看这几年的经历如何生成为“鸦片战争”的“历史叙述”。拉长镜头，尽可能贴近其中一个现场，顺时而观，从经历，到散落在时序中的记录，到秘密编纂的分类事务（夷务），到事件，再到划时代的事件。对照清朝自身的“事件”生产机制，可以看清在不同目的的驱使下，时人的经历与处置、事后诸人的思考、外人的叙述如何交汇，时人如何“失语”，后人如何控制了历史叙述，“事件”如何从经历中脱颖而出、意义又是如何被不断增添、改变与筛减的，“事件”形成后又如何变为重返历史现场的一层障碍。了解这些，我们便有可能从更多的角度去重新发现这段历史，并对“事件史”的意义与局限有更真切的认识。

English Abstract

How an Event Was Produced

Xudong HOU

Available Online: 2019-11-01

Abstract: Through the Court Dairies of the Daoguang period, which is much more close to one of the original historical sites, we could see how the rich court affairs between 1838 and 1842 documented in it were selected and compiled as the lean narratives tabbed as the Opium War eventually by taking the Court Dairies of the intercalary month of 1832(Sep.) as a mirror. We will also make clear how the ruling group’s efforts finally has been transformed into an epoch-making event through a series steps from scattered and trivial matters on Sino-British battles due to opium trades kept in archives, then to the classified affairs (Barbarian matters) compiled secretly in 1850’s under Xianfeng’s decree, and to an event, by returning to the past along time sequence and close to one of the historical sites as much as possible. Comparing to Qing Empire’s own event-producing mechanism, we could distinguish how those contemporaries’ experiences, the recalling from people afterwards, and the narratives coming from later generations and outsiders combine together, how the contemporaries fall into the victim of aphasia finally, how the later generations dominate the voices of historical narratives, how the event was made depending on contemporaries experiences, how the significances has been added, distorted, and reduced interrelatedly and constantly, and how the event becomes a kind of hindrance for posterity if we want to return to the original historical site after the production of the event as a story. Understanding all of these, we could rediscover the history of these years from more diverse perspectives, and know much about the implications and limitations of the history of events as a way of thinking.

事件是如何生成的？—道光的日常与“鸦片战争”作为事件的形成

作者简介: 侯旭东，清华大学人文学院历史系教授（北京 100084）;

How an Event Was Produced

计量

通讯作者: 陈斌, bchen63@163.com

事件是如何生成的？

作者简介:侯旭东，清华大学人文学院历史系教授（北京 100084）

English Abstract

How an Event Was Produced

全文HTML

目录

事件是如何生成的？—道光的日常与“鸦片战争”作为事件的形成

作者简介: 侯旭东，清华大学人文学院历史系教授（北京 100084）;

How an Event Was Produced

计量

文章相关

通讯作者: 陈斌, bchen63@163.com

事件是如何生成的？

作者简介:侯旭东，清华大学人文学院历史系教授（北京 100084）

English Abstract

How an Event Was Produced

全文HTML

目录