经济思想、道路自信与历史演化（笔 谈）

经济思想、道路自信与历史演化（笔谈）

Economic Thought, Confidence of Way and Historical Evolution (Symposium)

Available Online: 2020-03-01

摘要: 马涛、施华提出封闭性的地理环境决定了中央集权的政治体制和国家为本位的中国传统经济思想的特点，也就决定了混合所有制的经济结构和以儒家伦理为主干的历史文化根基。钟祥财提出随着封建国家的建立，中国传统经济思想方法论中既有个人主义的方法论，也有整体主义的方法论，在社会经济快速发展的历史条件下如何实现经济思想方法论整体主义和个人主义的科学兼容，是中华文明真正步入现代潮流的关键所在。宋丙涛、张庭从两希合流与殷周之变探讨了东西方文明分流的历史基因，认为东西方文明演化路径差异可以从公共经济体制构建成败的差异上得到说明，批判了西方中心论者的错误观念，探讨了中国文明的现代化转型。周建波提出由于地理环境、土质结构的差异形成了东西方不同的文化风格和发展道路，中国文化的最大特点是由于超血缘农村公社瓦解较早而形成了重视血缘、重视国家的文化传统，同时通过中古时期佛教的传入对中国社会的影响论证了中国发展道路的特殊文化基因。
- 经济思想 /
- 道路自信 /
- 历史演化
Abstract: Ma Tao proposes that the closed geographic environment has determined the characteristics of the traditional Chinese economic thought for the total political system and state-as-standard, and determined an economic structure of mixed ownership and the historical-cultural foundation with Confucian ethics as the stem. Zhong Xiangcai puts forward that, with the establishment of the feudal state, there are both individualism and holism in methodology of traditional Chinese economic thought. It is the key to truly step into modern current for the Chinese civilization to realize a scientific combination of holism and individualism in economic methodology under the historical condition of a fast development of social economy. Song Bingtao and Zhang Ting probe the historical gene of East-West civilization division from Greece-Hebrew confluence and China’s change from Shang to Zhou Dynasties, and believe that the difference of the routes of East-West evolution of civilization can be expounded by the difference of success or failure of the construction of public economic system, thus to criticize the wrong idea of the West-centralism and to probe the modernization transformation of Chinese civilization. Zhou Jianbo holds that, because of the difference of geographical environment and soil composition which formed different cultural styles and roads of development in the East and the West, the most important character of Chinese culture formed a cultural tradition of attaching importance to ties of blood and the state because of the early disintegration of meta-blood countryside communes and, at the same time, demonstrates the special cultural gene of Chinese road of development through the influence of dissemination of Buddhism into Chinese society in middle-ancient period.
- economic thought /
- confidence of way /
- historical evolution
1. [1]
  周建波 . 中国道路的历史基因. 学术月刊, 2020, 52(3): 58-62.
2. [2]
  谢岳 . 国家转型的中国道路：一项比较历史分析. 学术月刊, 2023, 55(12): 62-72.
3. [3]
  葛劲峰 , 袁志刚 , 樊潇彦 . 理解全球化：基于“经济−社会−政治”体系共生演化视角的分析. 学术月刊, 2021, 53(8): 31-44.
4. [4]
  韦森 . 重读凯恩斯：萧条经济学的演化生成与理论挑战. 学术月刊, 2022, 54(3): 72-100.
5. [5]
  钟祥财 . 中西传统经济思想的比较研究. 学术月刊, 2020, 52(3): 50-53.
6. [6]
  陆铭 . 面向长期、全局、多维的发展：中国道路的政治经济学. 学术月刊, 2022, 54(3): 58-71, 109.
7. [7]
  苏力 . 历史中国的分配正义：实践与思想. 学术月刊, 2020, 52(3): 79-95.
8. [8]
  马涛 , 李卫 . 中西方传统经济思想特点的比较. 学术月刊, 2019, 51(2): 57-67.
9. [9]
  马涛 , 刘宇 . 中国传统人口经济思想的特点与启示. 学术月刊, 2022, 54(7): 70-79.
10. [10]
  张凤林 . 马克思的制度经济思想再认识. 学术月刊, 2021, 53(2): 50-64.
11. [11]
  陈旭东 , 程霖 . 中国传统经济思想研究与新时期中国经济学构建. 学术月刊, 2023, 55(1): 56-68.
12. [12]
  王德峰 , 张敏琪 . 论经济学的非历史性. 学术月刊, 2021, 53(7): 22-35.
13. [13]
  李井奎 . IS-LM模型：一个经济思想史的考察. 学术月刊, 2022, 54(8): 45-54.
14. [14]
  陈旭东 , 程霖 . 中国现代经济思想史研究与新时代学术话语体系构建. 学术月刊, 2019, 51(6): 45-52.
15. [15]
  段博，程霖 . 中国传统经济思想的现代转化：提炼标识性概念的视角. 学术月刊, 2024, 56(3): 5-19.
16. [16]
  张一兵 , 张福公 , 孔伟宇 , 吴婷 . 经济学话语与历史唯物主义发生学（笔谈）. 学术月刊, 2022, 54(6): 5-10.
17. [17]
  周业安 , 张海燕 . 行为经济学半个多世纪的演进：范式转换的历史轨迹. 学术月刊, 2023, 55(4): 91-99.
18. [18]
  田国强 , 陈旭东 . 制度的本质、变迁与选择——赫维茨制度经济思想诠释及其现实意义. 学术月刊, 2018, 50(01): 63-77.
19. [19]
  葛兆光 . 一个历史事件的旅行 ——“文艺复兴”在东亚近代思想和学术中的影响. 学术月刊, 2016, 48(03): 120-127.
20. [20]
  孟捷 . 剩余价值与中国特色社会主义政治经济学：一个思想史的考察. 学术月刊, 2021, 53(2): 65-74.

点击查看大图

计量

PDF下载量: 9
文章访问数: 1449
HTML全文浏览量: 172

通讯作者: 陈斌, bchen63@163.com

1.
沈阳化工大学材料科学与工程学院沈阳 110142

经济思想、道路自信与历史演化（笔谈）

网络出版日期: 2020-03-01

关键词:

摘要: 马涛、施华提出封闭性的地理环境决定了中央集权的政治体制和国家为本位的中国传统经济思想的特点，也就决定了混合所有制的经济结构和以儒家伦理为主干的历史文化根基。钟祥财提出随着封建国家的建立，中国传统经济思想方法论中既有个人主义的方法论，也有整体主义的方法论，在社会经济快速发展的历史条件下如何实现经济思想方法论整体主义和个人主义的科学兼容，是中华文明真正步入现代潮流的关键所在。宋丙涛、张庭从两希合流与殷周之变探讨了东西方文明分流的历史基因，认为东西方文明演化路径差异可以从公共经济体制构建成败的差异上得到说明，批判了西方中心论者的错误观念，探讨了中国文明的现代化转型。周建波提出由于地理环境、土质结构的差异形成了东西方不同的文化风格和发展道路，中国文化的最大特点是由于超血缘农村公社瓦解较早而形成了重视血缘、重视国家的文化传统，同时通过中古时期佛教的传入对中国社会的影响论证了中国发展道路的特殊文化基因。

Economic Thought, Confidence of Way and Historical Evolution (Symposium)

Available Online: 2020-03-01

Abstract: Ma Tao proposes that the closed geographic environment has determined the characteristics of the traditional Chinese economic thought for the total political system and state-as-standard, and determined an economic structure of mixed ownership and the historical-cultural foundation with Confucian ethics as the stem. Zhong Xiangcai puts forward that, with the establishment of the feudal state, there are both individualism and holism in methodology of traditional Chinese economic thought. It is the key to truly step into modern current for the Chinese civilization to realize a scientific combination of holism and individualism in economic methodology under the historical condition of a fast development of social economy. Song Bingtao and Zhang Ting probe the historical gene of East-West civilization division from Greece-Hebrew confluence and China’s change from Shang to Zhou Dynasties, and believe that the difference of the routes of East-West evolution of civilization can be expounded by the difference of success or failure of the construction of public economic system, thus to criticize the wrong idea of the West-centralism and to probe the modernization transformation of Chinese civilization. Zhou Jianbo holds that, because of the difference of geographical environment and soil composition which formed different cultural styles and roads of development in the East and the West, the most important character of Chinese culture formed a cultural tradition of attaching importance to ties of blood and the state because of the early disintegration of meta-blood countryside communes and, at the same time, demonstrates the special cultural gene of Chinese road of development through the influence of dissemination of Buddhism into Chinese society in middle-ancient period.